2015-05-21 SEC Meeting, Alkmaar

Owned by Thomas Beale
Last updated: 06-Feb-2020 by Sebastian Iancu

Problem Report discussion. SEC members: please add new PRs to this table as required, and update Vote / Discussion columns.

THIS IS NOW PRETTY WELL COMPLETE IN TERMS OF COVERAGE.

One of our main goals is to generate CRs that are spread out across the SEC members.


PRStatusDescriptionVOTE TO
PROGRESS 		PriorityPROPOSED ACTION

SPECPR-11

DEFER Need to specify a choice of different objects within a container attribute in Archetype and Template

Group construct - put off till AOM 2.1

SPECPR-24DEFERImproving Translation details and other_contributorsTB
Create CR, even though exact details not yet worked out

SPECPR-41

SPECPR-62

SPECPR-119


Enable content specific flavours of null to be specified per archetype

Add a 'reason for null' text attribute in the Reference model

CLUSTER also needs a Null_flavour


MAJOR

Flavours of Null PRs

REQUIRES DISCUSSION

SPECPR-43

DEFERMinor problem in Iso8601DateTime pattern defintion in XML-Schema

check with SI/Code24 and also Heath/Ocean

SPECPR-70


Simplify modelling of 'CodedWithExtensions' CWE pattern of DV_CODED_TEXT by addition of an 'unbounded' qualifier to defining_code constraint
MAJOR

REQUIRES DISCUSSION

The CWE question

SPECPR-73

SPECPR-74

SPECPR-106


These are all to do with simplifying the 'lower model' of the RM (ITEM_XXX classes)KAMAJOR

REQUIRES DISCUSSION

Designate one as the main PR, close and reference the two
others, and create a single CR in the RM component (exact
change unknown so far)

SPECPR-91


Add sibling_id to LOCATABLE so that child objects can be uniquely identified without relying on the name field
MAJORREQUIRES DISCUSSION

SPECPR-94


AOM node_id optionality rules not clear

propose: raise CR to rectify invariant to be optional in ADL 1.5; then in ADL 1.6 or ADL 1.7, bring in mandatory node_ids as per ADL 2

SPECPR-95


language on multiple locations contain invalid ISO 639-1 codesTB
propose to raise CR that fixes documentation.

SPECPR-98


Definition of DV_ENCAPSULATED is incorrect (SIZE missing)SIminor

SPECPR-99


AUDIT_DETAILS.system_id‏ semantics not well defined
minorREQUIRES DISCUSSION

SPECPR-101


Relax the rule that demands uniqueness of DV_ORDINAL value
minorREQUIRES DISCUSSION - IAN

SPECPR-103


Add instance level annotations capability to RM
MAJOR

REQUIRES DISCUSSION

TB: This is a variation on a common request; my view is that it has to be done with referencing and that doing it properly requires new RM.

SPECPR-104


PARTY.reverse_relationships should better be a Set<PARTY_REF> ?
minorREQUIRES DISCUSSION

SPECPR-105


VERSION commit in XML
minor?REQUIRES DISCUSSION (Pablo)
SPECPR-106
(see SPECPR-73)


SPECPR-107


Allow creating LINK archetypes to specify queryable links between concepts


MAJOR

REQUIRES DISCUSSION

this is the 'contains or references' idea

SPECPR-109


Do not require the @internal@ ontology term descriptions and "name" on instances of internal types
minorREQUIRES DISCUSSION
SPECPR-111
AUDIT_DETAILS.change_type needs to be empty in CONTRIBUTION.audit
MinorREQUIRES DISCUSSION

SPECPR-114


Use markdown for purpose, use, misuse, etc on archetypes
MAJORREQUIRES DISCUSSION

SPECPR-115


Specify ACCESS_ CONTROL_SETTINGS and a concrete subtype
MinorREQUIRES DISCUSSION (Heath)

SPECPR-116


Allow mapping to terminology for DV_Boolean
MinorREQUIRES DISCUSSION (Ian M)

SPECPR-117


Support newlines and formatted in DV_TEXT
MAJOR

REQUIRES DISCUSSION (all)

This is the recurring issue of DV_TEXT formatting

SPECPR-118
Support Clinical Finding pattern in RM (negation / absence / presence)KAMAJOR

Help reduce unnecessary clutter and improve modelling

REQUIRES DISCUSSION

need something in RM? - Ian - create wiki page



Template Data Schema?

TDO






Agenda


Thursday
10:00 - 11:00Informal - get set up with Jira, screens, GTM
11:00 - 11:45SEC business
  • introduction
    • SEC governance
  • goals of meeting
    • PR -> CR conversion
    • define & assign releases
    • share the work
  • the documentation situation
11:45 - 12:15Global review of PRs/CRs
  • Review releases of components
  • triage out: actionable / need discussion / defer
12:15 - 13:30LUNCH
13:30 - 14:00Code24 part 1
14:00 - 15:00PR / CR processing
15:00 - 15:15Coffee + Shinji / Japan update
15:15 - 16:45PR / CR processing
16:45 - 17:00break
17:00 - 17:30Code24 part 2
17:30 - 18:00PR / CR review
19:00 -Dinner


Friday
09:00 - 10:15Service model / APIs
10:15 - 10:30Coffee - Code24 system presentation
10:30 - 11:00Query result object
11:00 - 12:15PR / CR processing
12:15 - 13:15LUNCH
13:15 - 13:30Conformance priorities
13:30 - 14:30PR / CR processing
14:30 - 14:45Coffee
14:45 - 16:00specifications wrap-up

drinks? :)

Issues

Sebastian Iancu: UML
Release packages - issue of syncing releases of components e.g. RM and XSDs - needs dependency model like apt-get /RPMs/Maven/Ruby gems etc - e.g. Maven requires >= versionX 

Actions

  • UML/tooling etc - TB / Bostjan

APIs and Service Model discussion

Data services

  • Agree on priority to publish REST-based data service specification (EHR, demographics, EHR Index, access control...)
    • EhrScape is starting point
      • confirm no IP problem to convert to spec
    • OWNER: Bostjan Lah
  • Agree to update SOAP service definition
    • existing defs as starting point
    • OWNER: Heath Frankel / TB
  • Resources
  • Technical issues:
    • don't include anything to do with sessions in REST API - single-shot commits; treat session as a specific local SSO/auth problem

Business Services

E.g. Shared Care Plan, Shared Meds list etc

Application services

Content-generated FHIR-like resources - archetype- or template-based.
Basis should be AQL queries; named queries with parameters (Erik's paper)
Can defined pre-defined query sets for given FHIR resource.

Canonical Result Set

Marand JSON

Ocean (origina) XML